The mailing list for listmasters using Sympa

[David Verdin <address@concealed>]

Something's wrong with your scenario interpretation: the message 
shouldn't be rejected. Your scenario states that, should all the 
accepting rules fail, the message would be kept for moderation, not 
rejected.
I think that the scenario you showed us is not the one actually used by 
Sympa.

From the path you showed in your precedent message, I conclude that you 
use an install-specific scenario (it is located directly in 
/usr/local/etc/sympa/scenari).
As you're talking about 5.2 and 5.3.4, I guess you just upgraded, didn't 
you?
Then this is some things you could try:
1- check the pathes. Are your sure the pathes you sepcified at install 
time correspond to your precedent install? For example, the default 
install directory is /home/sympa/.
2- check the rights. Is Sympa able to read in the directory containing 
the scenario?
3- check that there is list or robot specific scenario. If the list 
directory contains a scenario, it will be used instead of the install 
specif one.
4- check the list config. No offense, but that kind of things can happen 
after all: are you sure your list is configured to use this scenario?

Hope this helps.

Regads,

Xavier Beaudouin a écrit :
> Hi there,
>
> Le 14 janv. 08 à 11:20, Xavier Beaudouin a écrit :
>
> > Hello,
> >
> > Le 14 janv. 08 à 03:51, David Verdin a écrit :
> >
> > > Hi,
> > >
> > > It is impossible to know why this message is sent to bad from the 
> > > informations you provide.
> > > Are you sure this email is the one the user is subscribed with ?
> > > What scenario send do you use?
> >
> > A custom one :
> >
> > [kiwi@lists /usr/local/etc/sympa/scenari]$ more 
> > send.privateoreditorkeycvs
> > title.us Private, for caudiumforge users and moderated for non 
> > subcribers
> >
> > match([sender], /@cvs.caudiumforge.net$/)       smtp,smime,md5  -> do_it
> > match([sender], /@users.sourceforge.net$/)      smtp,smime,md5  -> do_it
> > is_subscriber([listname],[sender])      smtp,smime,md5  -> do_it
> > is_editor([listname],[sender])          smtp,smime,md5  -> do_it
> > is_owner([listname],[sender])           smtp,smime,md5  -> do_it
> > true()                                  smtp,smime,md5  -> editorkey
> >
> > This scenario vas working on sympa 5.2..
>
> Seems that I found why :
>
> Jan 15 17:14:48 lists sympa[18667]: main::DoFile() Processing 
> /address@concealed ; 
> sender: Xavier Beaudouin <address@concealed>  ; message-id: 
> <address@concealed>
> Jan 15 17:14:48 lists sympa[18667]: main::DoMessage() Processing 
> message for openvisp-commits with priority 5, 
> <address@concealed>
> Jan 15 17:14:48 lists sympa[18667]: main::DoMessage() Message for 
> openvisp-commits from address@concealed rejected() because 
> sender not allowed
> Jan 15 17:14:49 lists sympa[18667]: Moving bad file 
> address@concealed to bad/
>
> Does match([sender], ...) has changed since sympa 5.2 ?
>
> /Xavier

--
David Verdin
Comité réseau des universités