Subject: The mailing list for listmasters using Sympa
List archive
- From: "Mail administrator, Otto Makela" <address@concealed>
- To: address@concealed
- Subject: Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To
- Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 12:51:38 +0300
On 09/10/2026 21.36, Matt Taggart wrote:
> Ok I think I understand now. I think you are saying:
>
> If sympa doesn't modify the Reply-To: then it should be possible for a
> message with a non-munged gmail sender and gmail DKIM signature to pass
> through and still verify on the receiving end.
>
> Is that what you are saying? And like you said it also can't modify
> the subject, or add a list footer (mime or plain). I think that might
> be possible.
It is, and this is what I am currently doing. As I said, the (these
days somewhat unfortunate) Sympa default is to add that "Reply-to",
and it took me much too long to figure out what was going wrong with
Google-originated messages.
> But the message is still going to arrive at the receiving end with a
> gmail sender and from a host that isn't SPF approved and will still
> likely have issues, right?
There are no SPF issues. Sympa changes the SMTP envelope sender¹
to be itself², and you of course have your own mailing list server
in your own domain's SPF allow list. This is the classic way SPF is
intended to work with mailing lists.
1. Sometimes confusingly referred to as "Sender", although it is not
the same thing as the similarly-named message header.
2. So that any possible bounces from the mailing list addresses end
up with it for processing.
Nobody has info on how to disable system-wide the Sympa "Reply-to" adding?
--
address@concealed (Mail Administrator, Otto J. Makela)
-
[en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Mail administrator, Otto Makela, 10/08/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Matt Taggart, 10/08/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Mail administrator, Otto Makela, 10/09/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Matt Taggart, 10/09/2026
- Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To, Mail administrator, Otto Makela, 10/12/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Matt Taggart, 10/09/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Mail administrator, Otto Makela, 10/09/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Matt Taggart, 10/08/2026
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19+.