Subject: The mailing list for listmasters using Sympa
List archive
- From: "Mail administrator, Otto Makela" <address@concealed>
- To: "address@concealed" <address@concealed>
- Subject: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To
- Date: Thu, 8 Oct 2026 17:53:34 +0300
A word of warning for those who try to run your Sympa mailing list
server so that SPF and DKIM rules get followed in the "classic" way.
Our mailing list has the SPF permission for its Sender address,
and we try to pass the message through unmolested, so the original
DKIM signatures verify.
Turns out that gmail.com (Google, and the domains hosted there)
produce a DKIM signature which includes the "Reply-To" header,
even if there is none in the outgoing message. Makes sense.
It also turns out that the Sympa default is to add a "Reply-To"
header for the original sender of the message, apparently to minimize
the possibility of people mistakenly answering to the whole list
when they are trying to send to the original sender.
These two, when combined, cause messages originating from gmail.com
that do not have a "Reply-To" header set to fail DKIM signatures
once they pass through a Sympa mailing list with default settings.
To avoid this problem from occurring, set these values in
Admin → Edit List Config → Sending/receiving setup:
Reply address (reply_to_header): other email address (other_email)
other email address (other_email): (empty)
respect of existing header field (apply): respect
Or directly edit the config file to set the values:
reply_to_header
value other_email
apply respect
Could someone point out the correct default values that could be added
to the system-wide sympa.conf? Apparently you just can't do things like:
reply_to_header.value other_email
--
address@concealed (Mail Administrator, Otto J. Makela)
-
[en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Mail administrator, Otto Makela, 10/08/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Matt Taggart, 10/08/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Mail administrator, Otto Makela, 10/09/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Matt Taggart, 10/09/2026
- Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To, Mail administrator, Otto Makela, 10/12/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Matt Taggart, 10/09/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Mail administrator, Otto Makela, 10/09/2026
-
Re: [en@sympa] Google, DKIM, and Reply-To,
Matt Taggart, 10/08/2026
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19+.