The mailing list for listmasters using Sympa

[kutukupret <address@concealed>]

hai david,
thanks for reponding my question :)

now my sympa works like a charm. as long as i remember i just create 
bounce directory in /var/sympa/
and run postalias hash:/etc/mail/sympa_aliases (why sympa web interface 
did not create db/hash sympa_aliases automaticaly?)

and everything is run correctly until now. both web interface and 
mailing list.

thanks

David Verdin wrote:
> Hari,
>
> Sorry it took so long to answer you.
> Your logs indicate that Sympa removes your message to prevent a loop. 
> There can be several reasons.
> Are all the messages rejected or only some of them ?
> I need to see a rejected message file to understand your problem. 
> Could you please send it ?
> Meanwhile, looking at the part of Sympa doc regarding loops prevention 
> could maybe enlighten you :
>
> http://www.sympa.org/wiki/manual/customizing#loop_detection
>
> Regards,
>
> kutukupret a écrit :
> [snip/]
> > what i have in mind is, why sympa always move subscriber post to 
> > /var/sympa/spool/msg/bad directory?
> > this is what i have in sympa.log and postfix log file:
> >
> > May  7 10:35:04 mail postfix/local[7372]: 15F3E24EF7E: 
> > to=<xxx@localhost>, orig_to=<address@concealed>, relay=local, 
> > delay=8.8, delays=7.6/0.02/0/1.2, dsn=2.0.0, status=sent (delivered 
> > to command:  /etc/smrsh/queue address@concealed)
> > May  7 13:07:45 mail sympa[14735]: Processing 
> > /address@concealed with 
> > priority 5
> > May  7 13:07:45 mail sympa[14735]: 
> > DoFile(/address@concealed)
> > May  7 13:07:45 mail sympa[14735]: 
> > Message::new(/address@concealed)  
> >
> > May  7 13:07:45 mail sympa[14735]: 
> > List::new(kutukupret,lists.kutukupret.com)
> > May  7 13:07:45 mail sympa[14735]: List::load(kutukupret, 
> > lists.kutukupret.com)
> > May  7 13:07:45 mail sympa[14735]: Setting log level with 
> > lists.kutukupret.com configuration (or sympa.conf) : 4
> > May  7 13:07:45 mail sympa[14735]: Ignoring message which would cause 
> > a loop, sent by address@concealed
> > May  7 13:07:45 mail sympa[14735]: Moving bad file 
> > address@concealed to bad/
> > May  7 13:07:45 mail sympa[14735]: Language::SetLang(us)
> > i followed postfix installation in www.sympa.org FAQs sections
> >
> > here is my sympa.conf
> >
> > home    /var/sympa/expl
> > etc     /etc/sympa
> > pidfile /var/run/sympa/sympa.pid
> > umask   027
> > localedir       /usr/lib/sympa/locale
> > spool   /var/sympa/spool
> > queue   /var/sympa/spool/msg
> > queuebounce     /var/sympa/spool/bounce
> > syslog  LOCAL1
> > log_socket_type unix
> > log_level       4
> > domain  lists.kutukupret.com
> > listmaster     address@concealed
> > email   address@concealed
> > lang    us
> > create_list     public_listmaster
> > cookie  79580759
> > max_size        5242880
> > rfc2369_header_fields   help,subscribe,unsubscribe,post,owner,archive
> > remove_headers          
> > Return-Receipt-To,Precedence,X-Sequence,Disposition-Notification-To
> > bounce_warn_rate        30
> > bounce_halt_rate        50
> > expire_bounce_task      daily
> > welcome_return_path     owner
> > remind_return_path      owner
> > sendmail        /usr/sbin/sendmail.postfix
> > nrcpt   25
> > avg     10
> > maxsmtp 40
> > db_type mysql
> > db_name xxx
> > db_host localhost
> > db_port 3306
> > db_user xxx
> > db_passwd  xxx
> > wwsympa_url     http://lists.kutukupret.com/wws
> >
> > here is what i have in postfix main.cf and master.cf
> >
> > main.cf:
> > alias_maps = hash:/etc/postfix/aliases, hash:/etc/mail/sympa_aliases
> > virtual_alias_maps = 
> > proxy:mysql:/etc/postfix/mysql_virtual_alias_maps.cf, 
> > regexp:/etc/postfix/virtual_regexp
> > transport_maps = hash:/etc/postfix/transport, 
> > regexp:/etc/postfix/transport_regexp
> >
> > sympa_aliases was generated by web interface when creating new list.
> >
> > transport_regexp:
> > /^.*+owner\@lists\.kutukupret\.com$/    sympabounce:
> > /^.*\@lists\.kutukupret\.com$/          sympa:
> >
> > virtual_regexp:
> > /^(.*)-owner\@(.*)$/    $1+owner@$2
> > /^(.*)\@lists\.kutukupret\.com$/        $1
> > /^(.*)-request\@lists\.kutukupret\.com$/        $1-request
> > /^(.*)-editor\@lists\.kutukupret\.com$/         $1-editor
> > /^(.*)-subscribe\@lists\.kutukupret\.com$/      $1-subscribe
> > /^(.*)-unsubscribe\@lists\.kutukupret\.com$/    $1-unsubscribe
> >
> > master.cf:
> > sympa        unix  -       n       n       -       -       pipe
> >  flags=R user=sympa argv=/etc/smrsh/queue ${recipient}
> > sympabounce  unix  -       n       n       -       -       pipe
> >  flags=R user=sympa argv=/etc/smrsh/bouncequeue ${user}
> >
> > am i missed something here?
> > why subscriber post always move to /var/sympa/spool/msg/bad directory?
> >
> > need enlightenment please :)
> >
> > thank you